Free NCERT/CBSE Learning Resources — Class 6-12 Video Lectures + Notes — Hindi, English, Hinglish
म NCERT textbook study material
Class 6-12 • Free forever

Home / Class 10 / Hindi / Kshitij / Stri-shiksha ke virodhi kutarkon ka khandan (file jhks115)

स्त्री-शिक्षा के विरोधी कुतर्कों का खंडन

महावीरप्रसाद द्विवेदी का निबंध

Mahavir Prasad Dwivedi ka nibandh: stri-shiksha ke virodhi kutarkon ka khandan

Long + Short notes Hindi • English • Hinglish Archived NCERT Hindi textbook Kshitij, chapter file jhks115 (print stamp seen on its pages: 2022-23). This page is read from a copy of the NCERT PDF kept by the Internet Archive (Wayback Machine). The class is not printed on the chapter pages. The Kshitij book front pages we have (file jhks1ps, print stamp Reprint 2026-27) list 12 chapters and do not list this one, so this chapter file may belong to another edition of Kshitij. Its class and its place in the current book are not established here. This page makes no claim about the current syllabus. The file was read in full (11 pages): author page, the NCERT box, the essay, Prashn-abhyas Q1 to Q6, Rachna aur abhivyakti Q7 and Q8, Bhasha-adhyayan Q9, Patheytar sakriyata, Shabd-sampada, Yah bhi jaanen and the printed passage on Pandita Ramabai. This is a polemic essay first printed in 1914 (as the NCERT box says). Its claims about ancient texts, ancient society, languages and the examples it names (such as Shakuntala, Sita, Gargi, Rukmini, flying machines) are the author's own arguments as printed, not separately checked here. The box says NCERT did not revise the essay's language or spelling. Notes are summaries and analysis, not a reproduction of the text. Opinion, writing and grammar tasks are not answered or keyed here.

Interactive Visual Walkthrough

long + short notes in Hindi, English, Hinglish. Summary and analysis of the essay Stri-shiksha ke virodhi kutarkon ka khandan (Mahavir Prasad Dwivedi).

Walkthrough Kholo →

Long Notes — Full Explanation

Concept pakka karne ke liye — aaram se padho

Notes language:

1️⃣ Lekhak aur NCERT box ⭐⭐⭐

  • NCERT ke author page ke anusar Mahavir Prasad Dwivedi ka janm 1864 mein gram Daulatpur, zila Raebareli (U.P.) mein hua. Aarthik sthiti achchi na hone se unhone railway mein naukri ki, phir istifa dekar 1903 mein Hindi masik patrika Saraswati ka sampadan shuru kiya aur 1920 tak jude rahe. Unka dehant 1938 mein hua.
  • Page ke anusar wo Hindi ke pehle vyavasthit sampadak, bhashavaigyanik, itihaskar, puratatvavetta, arthshastri aur samalochak the. Pramukh kritiyan: Rasagya ranjan, Sahitya-seekar, Sahitya-sandarbh, Adbhut aalap (nibandh sangrah), Sampattishastra, Mahila mod, Adhyatmiki, Dwivedi kavya mala; sampurn sahitya Mahavir Prasad Dwivedi rachnavali ke 15 khandon mein. Page ke anusar unki lekhan-visheshta vidwata, bahugyata ke saath sarasta hai aur unke lekhan mein vyangya ki chhata hai.
  • NCERT box ke anusar ye lekh pehli baar September 1914 ki Saraswati mein Padhe-likhon ka pandity sheershak se chhapa; baad mein Mahila mod pustak mein shamil karte samay sheershak Stri-shiksha ke virodhi kutarkon ka khandan rakha gaya. Box ke anusar NCERT ne bhasha aur vartani ko sanshodhit karne ka prayas nahin kiya hai. Box ye bhi kehta hai ki is lekh ki ek visheshta ye hai ki isme parampara ko jyon ka tyon nahin sweekara gaya, balki vivek se lene yogya ko lene aur sad-gal chuki cheez ko roodhi maan chhodne ki baat hai.

💡 1864 Daulatpur, Saraswati 1903-1920, 1938; lekh pehle 1914 mein, sheershak Padhe-likhon ka pandity.

2️⃣ Virodhiyon ke tark aur Prakrit ka jawab ⭐⭐⭐

  • Lekh ke shuru mein lekhak ke anusar kuchh sushikshit log bhi maante hain ki striyon ko padhana unke aur grih-sukh ke nash ka karan hai. Unke tark lekhak ne is tarah diye: (1) puraane Sanskrit natakon mein kulin striyon se apadhon ki bhasha mein baat karayi gayi, isliye striyon ko padhane ki chaal na thi; (2) padhane se anarth hote hain, jaise Shakuntala ne Dushyant ko katu vakya kahe; (3) Shakuntala ne apadhon ki bhasha mein shlok racha.
  • Lekhak ka jawab (unke shabdon ke anusar): natakon mein striyon ka Prakrit bolna unke apadh hone ka praman nahin; adhik se adhik ye ki wo Sanskrit nahin bol sakti thin. Unke anusar us zamane mein Prakrit hi sarvasadharan ki bhasha thi, isliye Bauddhon aur Jainon ke hazaron granth Prakrit mein likhe gaye, Shakya muni aur unke chele Prakrit mein dharmopadesh dete the aur Tripitak ki rachna bhi Prakrit mein hui. Hindi, Bangla ko wo aaj ki Prakrit batate hain.
  • Wo vyangya mein poochhte hain ki jin panditon ne Gatha-saptashati, Setubandh, Kumarpalcharit Prakrit mein banaye wo agar apadh the to Hindi ke prasiddh akhbar ka sampadak bhi apadh kaha ja sakta hai. Lekhak ke anusar jab Natyashastra ke niyam bane tab sarvasadharan ki bhasha Sanskrit na thi, chune hue log hi Sanskrit bolte the, isliye unhone stri aur anya logon ki bhasha Prakrit rakhne ka niyam kiya.

💡 Prakrit bolna = apadh nahin; Prakrit sarvasadharan ki bhasha (lekhak ke anusar).

3️⃣ Padhi-likhi striyon ke udaharan aur 'niyambaddh pranali' ⭐⭐⭐

  • Virodhi kehte hain ki striyon ko padhane ki niyambaddh pranali puraanon mein nahin milti. Lekhak ka tark: puraane zamane mein striyon ke liye koi vishwavidyalaya na tha, to pranali ka ullekh na milna kya aashcharya; ya ullekh raha ho aur nasht ho gaya ho. Udaharan ke taur par wo kehte hain ki us zamane mein viman udte the aur jahazon se dwipantar ki yatra hoti thi, par banane ki vidya sikhane wala shastra nahin milta. Ye lekhak ka tark hai; ise aitihasik daava ke roop mein yahan alag se jaancha nahin gaya.
  • Lekhak ne naamon ke udaharan diye: Vishwavara (ved-mantra ki rachayita), Sheela aur Vijja, Therigatha mein sankalit striyon ki kavita, Atri ki patni, Gargi, Mandan Mishra ki sahadharmacharini jo Shankaracharya ko shastrarth mein haraati hain (lekhak ke anusar). Unka vyangya: agar ye sab padhi-likhi thin to ye sab paapi padhne ka aparadh hai, aur striyon ke liye padhna kalkut, purushon ke liye piyush ka ghoont.
  • Lekhak Shrimadbhagwat ke Dashamskandh ke uttarardh ka 53wan adhyay padhne ko kehte hain jismein Rukmini-haran ki katha hai. Unke anusar Rukmini ne Shrikrishna ko lamba-chauda patra likha aur uske Prakrit mein hone ka ullekh Bhagwat mein nahin; uska pandity uske apadh ya alpagya hone ka soochak nahin. Wo maan bhi lein ki puraane zamane mein ek bhi stri padhi-likhi na thi, to bhi lekhak ke anusar ab to zarurat hai, isliye padhana chahiye.

💡 Niyambaddh pranali ka na milna = na hone ka praman nahin (lekhak ka tark); Vishwavara, Gargi, Rukmini ka patra.

4️⃣ Shakuntala, Sita aur nishkarsh ⭐⭐⭐

  • Lekhak ke anusar stri ka kiya anarth agar padhane ka parinam hai to purushon ka kiya anarth bhi unki vidya aur shiksha ka parinam samajhna chahiye: bam ke gole phenkna, narhatya, daake, chori, ghoos. Tab saare college aur school band ho jane chahiye; aisi dalilein vikshipt, batvyathit aur grahgrast logon ke siwa kam milengi (lekhak ke shabd).
  • Lekhak ke anusar Shakuntala ne apmanit hokar Dushyant ko jo katu vakya kahe wo swabhavik the, padhne ka parinam nahin. Wo Sita ka udaharan dete hain: jis kavi ne Shakuntala ke natak mein katu vakya kahlaye, usi ne parityakt Sita se Ramchandra ke liye sandesh kahlaya; lekhak ke anusar wo kisi ganvar stri ki ukti nahin, balki Raja Janak ki ladki ki hai. Wo kehte hain ki Sita ka katuvakya kehna sarvatha swabhavik hai, na padhne-likhne ka parinam, na ganvarpan ka.
  • Nishkarsh (lekhak ke shabd): padhne-likhne mein anarth ka beej nahin; anarth purushon se bhi hote hain, apadhon aur padhe-likhon, dono se. Striyon ko avashya padhana chahiye. Jo kehte hain ki puraane zamane mein striyan na padhti thin, wo ya to itihas se anbhigya hain ya jaan-boojhkar logon ko dhokha dete hain; striyon ko nirakshar rakhne ka updesh samaj ka apkar hai.
  • Lekhak ke anusar shiksha bahut vyapak shabd hai; vartaman shiksha-pranali achchi nahin, to use sanshodhit karna chahiye, na ki padhne ko dosh dena. Ladkon ki pranali bhi bahut achchi nahin, par kisi ne school-college band karne ki rai nahin di.

💡 Pranali sudharo, padhai ko dosh mat do.

Short Notes — Quick Revision

Exam se pehle sirf yeh dohrao

Notes language:

The author

  • Mahavir Prasad Dwivedi, 1864 to 1938
  • Railway job, then editor of Saraswati
  • Essay first printed in 1914 (box)

Opponents

  • Women in plays speak Prakrit
  • Harm from teaching, like Shakuntala
  • No formal system recorded

The replies

  • Prakrit was the common language (author)
  • Learned women named by the author
  • Missing records prove nothing (author)

The conclusion

  • Men's harms are not blamed on learning
  • Teach women; revise the system
  • Do not blame reading itself

Open

  • Q5 to Q9
  • Patheytar tasks
  • Not keyed

Practice — 5 Questions

Pehle khud solve karo, phir answer dekho.

Q1 Stri-shiksha ke virodhi kutarkon ka khandan Prashn-abhyas 1: kuchh puratan panthi log striyon ki shiksha ke virodhi the. Dwivedi ji ne kya-kya tark dekar stri-shiksha ka samarthan kiya
Answer dekho

Text mein stated (lekhak ke tark): (1) natakon mein striyon ka Prakrit bolna unke apadh hone ka praman nahin, kyonki us zamane mein Prakrit sarvasadharan ki bhasha thi (Tripitak, Bauddh-Jain granth). (2) Niyambaddh pranali ka ullekh na milna na hone ka praman nahin: ho sakta hai nasht ho gaya ho. (3) Vishwavara, Sheela, Vijja, Gargi, Rukmini jaise udaharan. (4) Shakuntala aur Sita ke katu vakya swabhavik the, padhne ka parinam nahin. (5) Anarth purushon se bhi hote hain; unka karan padhai nahin. (6) Shiksha ki pranali ko sudharna chahiye, padhne ko dosh nahin dena chahiye. (7) Agar puraane zamane mein striyan na padhti bhi hon, to ab zarurat hai.

Q2 Stri-shiksha ke virodhi kutarkon ka khandan Prashn-abhyas 2: striyon ko padhane se anarth hote hain, kutarkvadiyon ki is daleel ka khandan Dwivedi ji ne kaise kiya hai, apne shabdon mein likhiye
Answer dekho

Text mein stated: lekhak ke anusar stri ka kiya anarth agar padhane ka parinam hai, to purushon ka kiya anarth (bam ke gole phenkna, narhatya, daake, chori, ghoos) bhi unki padhai ka parinam mana jana chahiye, aur tab saare college-school band kar dene chahiye. Shakuntala ke katu vakya swabhavik the, Sita ka sandesh bhi katu tha jabki wo shastra-gyan rakhne wali rani thin. Lekhak ke anusar padhne-likhne mein anarth ka beej nahin; anarth apadhon aur padhe-likhon, dono se hota hai aur use chal-chalan se jaana ja sakta hai.

Q3 Stri-shiksha ke virodhi kutarkon ka khandan Prashn-abhyas 3: Dwivedi ji ne vyangya ka sahara liya hai, jaise yah sab papi padhne ka aparadh hai. Aap aise anya anshon ko nibandh mein se chhantkar samajhiye aur likhiye
Answer dekho

Text mein stated, vyangya wali panktiyan (lekhak ke shabd): Tarkshastragyata aur nyayasheelta ki balihari! (jab wo virodhiyon ka tark kaat te hain); Gajab! Isse adhik bhayankar baat aur kya ho sakegi!; Striyon ke liye padhna kalkut aur purushon ke liye piyush ka ghoont!; Sheela, Vijja aur Atri ki patni jaisi padhi-likhi striyon par wo kehte hain ki yah sab papi padhne ka aparadh hai. Inme lekhak ulte shabdon se virodhiyon ke tark ka uphas karte hain. Ye meri chhanti hui sooch hai; page par aur anshon ko bhi isi tarah padha ja sakta hai.

Q4 Stri-shiksha ke virodhi kutarkon ka khandan Prashn-abhyas 4: puraane samay mein striyon dwara Prakrit bhasha mein bolna kya unke apadh hone ka saboot hai, paath ke aadhar par spasht kijiye
Answer dekho

Text mein stated (lekhak ke anusar): nahin. Natakon mein Prakrit bolna adhik se adhik ye batata hai ki wo Sanskrit nahin bol sakti thin, jo na apadh hone ka saboot hai na ganvar hone ka. Us zamane mein Prakrit hi sarvasadharan ki bhasha thi; Bauddhon aur Jainon ke hazaron granth, Shakya muni ka dharmopadesh aur Tripitak Prakrit mein hain. Jin panditon ne Gatha-saptashati, Setubandh, Kumarpalcharit Prakrit mein banaye wo apadh nahin ho sakte. Natyashastra banane ke samay chune hue log hi Sanskrit bolte the, isliye striyon ke liye Prakrit ka niyam bana.

Q5 Open and practice tasks, not answered or keyed: Stri-shiksha ke virodhi kutarkon ka khandan Q5 se Q9 aur Patheytar
Answer dekho

Q5 (parampara ke kin pakshon ko sweekar kiya jana chahiye jo stri-purush samanta ko badhate hon, tark sahit uttar) vichar-pradhan hai; box ke anusar lekh mein vivek se lene yogya ko lene aur sad-gal chuki roodhi ko chhodne ki baat hai, par uttar likhna aapki rai ka kaam hai. Q6 (tab ki aur ab ki shiksha-pranali mein antar) ke liye page tab ki pranali ka koi taiyaar vivaran nahin deta; sirf ye kehta hai ki vartaman pranali achchi nahin, isliye Q6 yahan nahin kiya gaya. Q7 (nibandh dooragami aur khuli soch ka parichayak kaise) aur Q8 (bhasha-shaili par anuchchhed) rachna aur vyakhya ke kaam hain. Q9 (chaal, dal, patra, hara, par, phal, kul ko aise vakyon mein prayog karna ki unke ek se adhik arth spasht hon) Bhasha-adhyayan ka abhyas hai. Patheytar mein dadi-nani-maa se baat karke us samay ki sthitiyon se tulna karte hue nibandh, ladkiyon ki shiksha par jaagrukta ke upay, stri-shiksha par poster aur nukkad natak shamil hain; ye kaam yahan nahin kiye gaye. Shabd-sampada aur Yah bhi jaanen (Bhavabhuti, Vishwavara, Sheela, Therigatha, Anusuya, Gargi, Gatha-saptashati, Kumarpalcharit, Tripitak, Shakya muni, Natyashastra, Kalidas) page par hain, aur ek alag passage Pandita Ramabai ke bare mein hai: page ke anusar 1889 mein Mumbai mein Congress ke paanchwen adhiveshan mein unke prayas se 9 mahila pratinidhi shamil hui thin.

Subject index: Class 10 Hindi - sabhi chapters