Free NCERT/CBSE Learning Resources - Class 6-12 Video Lectures + Notes - Hindi, English, Hinglish
म NCERT/CBSE aligned study material
Class 6-12 • Free forever

Home / Class 10 / English / Footprints without Feet / Chapter 6

The Making of a Scientist

एक वैज्ञानिक का बनना

Robert W. Peterson on Richard Ebright, butterflies and a scientific mind

Long + Short notes Hindi • English • Hinglish NCERT Class X English, Footprints without Feet (supplementary reader), chapter file jefp106 (no print stamp was seen on this file, so it is labelled by file name only). The answers to Talk about it 1 come from the appendix page printed in chapter file jefp109. The whole chapter was retrieved, with the Read and Find Out questions, glossary, Think about it, Talk about it and Suggested reading. These notes are summaries and analysis, not a reproduction of the text. All facts about Richard Ebright are the chapter's own statements as written for its time (he is described as a 22-year-old graduate student, and his theory as not yet proven); nothing is checked against later sources. The butterfly species list and the graph are not reproduced. Think about it 1 and 2 and Talk about it 1 and 2 are open and are not keyed

Interactive Visual Walkthrough

long + short notes in Hindi, English, Hinglish. Summary and analysis of The Making of a Scientist (Robert W. Peterson), with answers to the factual Read and Find Out questions.

Walkthrough Kholo →

Long Notes - Full Explanation

Concept pakka karne ke liye - aaram se padho

Notes language:

1️⃣ Richard Ebright kaun? ⭐⭐⭐

  • The Making of a Scientist Robert W. Peterson ka lekh hai. Chapter ke anusar baais saal ki umar mein purane scout of the year Richard H. Ebright ne cells ke kaam karne ki nayi theory par vigyan-jagat ko chaunka diya.
  • Theory ek article mein Proceedings of the National Academy of Science mein chhapi. Chapter kehta hai ki is journal ne pehli baar college students ka kaam chhapa. Ye sab titliyon se shuru hua.
  • Ebright akela bachcha tha aur Reading, Pennsylvania ke north mein pala. Usne titliyan, pathar, fossils, sikke jama kiye aur raat bhar taare bhi dekhta tha.

💡 Peterson, 22 saal, titliyan, akela bachcha.

2️⃣ Maa ka saath ⭐⭐⭐

  • Uski maa ne seekhne ka shauk badhaya: telescope, microscope, camera aur dusra saamaan diya aur safar par le gayi. Pita ke guzar jaane ke baad (third grade mein) Ebright maa ki poori zindagi tha.
  • Maa ne kaha ki wo har shaam use seekhne wale kaam deti thi, shaarirak kaam nahi. Doosri class tak Ebright ne apne shehar ki pachchis titli-prajatiyan jama kar li thi.
  • Ye Read and Find Out ka jawab hai ki maa ne uski kaise madad ki.

💡 Telescope, microscope, shaam ka kaam, 25 prajatiyan.

3️⃣ Monarch X aur tagging ⭐⭐⭐

  • Maa ne use bacchon ki kitaab The Travels of Monarch X di. Chapter ke anusar isne use monarch titliyon ke Central America jaane ke baare mein bataya aur vigyan ki duniya khol di.
  • Kitaab mein pathakon ko tagging mein madad ke liye bulaya gaya tha, Dr Frederick A. Urquhart (University of Toronto) ke liye. Maa ne unhe khat likha aur Ebright monarchs ke pankhon par halke adhesive tag lagane laga.
  • Usne mada monarch ke ande lekar basement mein titliyan paali, aur kai saal wahan hazaaron monarchs the. Baad mein tagging tedious lagi: Ebright ke anusar sirf do tagged titliyan wapas mili, pachhattar mile ke andar.

💡 Monarch X, Urquhart, tags, basement, sirf do wapas.

4️⃣ Science fair ka sabak ⭐⭐⭐

  • Saatvin class mein county science fair mein Ebright ki entry frog tissue ki slides thi. Wo kuch nahi jeeta. Use samajh aaya ki jeetne walon ne asli experiment kiye the, sirf sundar display nahi.
  • Usne Dr Urquhart se idea maange aur aathvin class mein monarch caterpillars ki viral bimari ke karan par kaam kiya (kya beetle failata hai). Chapter ke anusar asli natija nahi aaya, par experiment dikhane par jeet mili.
  • Agle saal usne ye theory jaanchi ki viceroy monarch ki nakal karte hain. Chapter ke anusar ek starling saadha khana nahi khata, par saare monarchs kha leta tha. Ebright ke anusar baad ki research ne dikhaya ki viceroy shayad nakal karte hain.

💡 Frog slides, haar, asli experiment, viceroy aur starling.

5️⃣ Gold spots aur theory ⭐⭐⭐

  • Chapter ke anusar high school mein usne puchha: monarch pupa par baarah chhote sunehri dhabbe kis kaam ke? Sab maante the ki ye sirf sajaavat hain, par Urquhart ko vishwas nahi tha.
  • Chapter ke anusar dhabbe ek hormone bana rahe the jo titli ke poore vikas ke liye zaroori tha. Isse use county aur International Science and Engineering Fair mein inaam mile aur army tatha agriculture labs mein kaam mila.
  • Harvard mein junior year mein hormone ki X-ray photos dekhte hue use apni cell theory ka idea aaya: cell apne DNA blueprint ko kaise padhta hai. Usne room-mate James R. Wong ke saath raat bhar models banaye aur paper likha.

💡 Baarah dhabbe, hormone, X-ray photos, DNA, Wong.

6️⃣ Ek scientist ke gun ⭐⭐⭐

  • Chapter ke anusar Ebright Harvard se highest honours ke saath, 1,510 mein doosre number par nikla, aur Harvard Medical School mein theory ke experiments shuru kiye. Chapter keh raha hai ki agar theory sahi nikli, to cancer jaisi bimariyon ko rokne ke naye idea mil sakte hain.
  • Wo debater, canoeist aur photographer bhi tha. Teacher Mr Weiherer ne kaha ki Ebright jeetne ke liye nahi balki best kaam karne ke liye jeetna chahta tha.
  • Chapter ka formula: first-rate mind, curiosity aur sahi karano se jeetne ki ichha. Ye bhi khule sawal hain: scientist kaise bante hain, aur aap kaunsa field chunenge (Think about it, Talk about it).

💡 Harvard, Weiherer, mind plus curiosity plus sahi iraada.

Short Notes - Quick Revision

Exam se pehle sirf yeh dohrao

Notes language:

Ebright

  • Robert W. Peterson writes about him
  • At 22 a new cell theory (chapter)
  • It started with butterflies

His mother

  • Telescopes, microscopes, trips
  • Learning work in the evenings
  • 25 butterfly species by second grade

Monarchs

  • The Travels of Monarch X
  • Tagging for Dr Urquhart
  • Only two tagged butterflies came back

Science fair

  • Seventh grade: frog slides, no prize
  • Real experiments win
  • Viceroys and the starling

The theory

  • Twelve gold spots, a hormone
  • X-ray photos, DNA blueprint
  • Room-mate James R. Wong

Practice - 9 Questions

Pehle khud solve karo, phir answer dekho.

Q1 Read and Find Out 1: how did a book become a turning point in Ebright's life
Answer dekho

His mother got him a children's book, The Travels of Monarch X, which told how monarch butterflies migrate to Central America. It opened the world of science to him, and he began tagging monarchs for Dr Urquhart.

Q2 Read and Find Out 1 (part 2): how did his mother help him
Answer dekho

She took him on trips, bought him telescopes, microscopes, cameras and other equipment, brought home friends for him, gave him learning work in the evenings, and wrote to Dr Urquhart about tagging.

Q3 Read and Find Out 2: what lesson does Ebright learn when he does not win at a science fair
Answer dekho

With his slides of frog tissues he won nothing. He realised the winners had tried to do real experiments, not simply make a neat display, so he would have to do a real experiment the next year.

Q4 Read and Find Out 2 (part 2): what experiments and projects does he then undertake
Answer dekho

Eighth grade: the cause of a viral disease that kills monarch caterpillars (testing a beetle). Next: whether viceroys copy monarchs, using a starling. Then: the purpose of the twelve gold spots on a monarch pupa, which led to the hormone and later his cell theory.

Q5 Read and Find Out 3: what are the qualities that go into the making of a scientist
Answer dekho

The chapter says: a first-rate mind, curiosity, and the will to win for the right reasons.

Q6 Talk about it 1 (i): what is DNA fingerprinting, and what are its uses (as answered by Professor Yash Pal and Dr Rahul Pal)
Answer dekho

Summary of the answer printed on the appendix page of chapter file jefp109 (taken from Discovered Questions, NCERT, 2006): DNA is made of strands of bases that carry genetic information specific to each living thing. Enzymes break a person's DNA into fragments of different sizes, which move at different rates in an electric field and give a unique pattern, called a DNA fingerprint. Uses named there: showing parentage, and forensic science (a single hair or a tiny spot of blood can help show the innocence or guilt of a suspect, and identify remains after accidents). The text adds that it has been suggested, as of that book, that DNA profiles might one day be needed for ID cards, bank accounts and driving licences, that human rights groups call this an invasion of privacy, and that the technology can be abused. These are the authors' statements as printed, not checked against later sources.

Q7 Talk about it 1 (ii): how do honeybees identify their own honeycombs (as answered by Professor Yash Pal and Dr Rahul Pal)
Answer dekho

Summary of the printed answer: honeybees are very good at position, location and navigation. They use the sun as a guide and appear to have a good memory. They tell the hive about a new food source through a dance that shows the direction and distance of the food relative to the sun, and if a light bulb is switched on in a dark hive the dance includes the bulb as a reference direction. The authors say that bees have a kind of pictorial memory, a direction-finding mechanism and a way of reckoning distance, so they are probably better equipped for getting home than we are. The appendix answers how bees find their way home; it does not state a separate method for recognising their own combs.

Q8 Talk about it 1 (iii): why does rain fall in drops (as answered by Professor Yash Pal and Dr Rahul Pal)
Answer dekho

Summary of the printed answer: rain is the result of condensation of vapour when air is cooled below the dew point. All the vapour in a cloud cannot condense at once and make a large pool of water. Pockets of air move up independently and cool slowly until condensation begins and droplets form. The authors say it is believed that most raindrops start as tiny ice crystals that float down, gather more moisture, and melt into droplets at lower altitudes; in colder climates the crystals reach the ground as snowflakes.

Q9 Pending, not keyed
Answer dekho

Think about it 1 (how one can become a scientist, an economist, a historian) and 2 (Ebright's work in the light of what you have studied, and which field you would choose), and Talk about it 2 (share your own questions and try to answer them): all are open questions. The three Talk about it 1 questions are answered above from the appendix page, which sits in chapter file jefp109 (print stamp Reprint 2025-26), not in jefp106.

Subject index: Class 10 English - sabhi chapters